Name: Lake Hiawatha Dairy
Price range: $$

Lake Hiawatha Dairy Information

If you find yourself cruising down N Beverwyck Rd in Lake Hiawatha, NJ, and you're craving a place that feels like home with comforting food and friendly faces, Lake Hiawatha Dairy is the spot to check out. Tucked in a cozy corner, this classic diner delivers a laid-back, nostalgic atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time, but with a modern twist.

Walking through the door, you’re greeted by the kind of warmth that only a neighborhood diner can offer. The space feels inviting and casual, perfect for anything from a quick bite to a more relaxed meal with friends. The retro vibe adds to the charm, with checkered floors and the kind of friendly banter you'd expect from a place where everyone knows your name-or at least your usual order.

The menu is a dream for those who appreciate a solid, traditional diner experience. Breakfast lovers will feel right at home with options like fluffy pancakes, perfectly crispy bacon, and eggs done just how you like them. If you’re in the mood for something heartier, the lunch and dinner options don't disappoint. From juicy burgers to comforting sandwiches and home-style dinners, there’s something to satisfy every craving. For a local favorite, try the homemade meatloaf-tender, flavorful, and paired with mashed potatoes that are the perfect balance of creamy and buttery.

What really sets Lake Hiawatha Dairy apart, though, is the service. The staff here is genuinely friendly, offering that warm, welcoming vibe that makes you feel like you're more than just another customer. Whether you're a regular or a first-timer, they'll make you feel at home, and it’s clear that they take pride in serving up meals that make people happy.

Another highlight is the bakery section. If you have a sweet tooth, don’t miss out on their freshly baked pies or the homemade cakes. You can’t go wrong with any of the options, but the apple pie is a must-try. It’s baked to perfection with just the right balance of tart and sweet, and the crust is buttery and flaky.

Overall, Lake Hiawatha Dairy has all the elements of a fantastic local diner. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual breakfast or grabbing a satisfying lunch, the food, service, and ambiance make it a place worth returning to. It’s the kind of spot where you can grab a bite and enjoy the relaxed, community feel, making it a true gem in Lake Hiawatha.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Came in for a late night treat and the soft-serve was exactly what I was looking for! Food: The large helping of soft-serve was super creamy and delicious down to the last bite. And even though the summer heat is starting to set in the soft serve held-up and melted very slowly. Service: The friendly staff was very quick with our orders and with all the different ice cream flavors that enticed me, I will definitely make many return trips. Atmosphere: This place has the energy of a local staple. It’s easy to imagine coming here with your basketball team after a game or after some finals. The seating area is also a big plus if you want to just sit, eat your ice cream, and chat.

Went in for a sugar free ice cream the options where vanilla or chocolate choose the chocolate but i think it was some kind of cake batter chocolate ice cream ( I do not like cake batter, cookie dough etc…..) Which there were more sugar free options

Gave them less than 24 hours notice and they turned around with an amazingly looking and tasting ice cream cake! Loved the taste - as always! Been having their ice creams and ice-cream cakes for the last few years now and it is all soo good! Especially the “Mother Earth” and soft serves… Highly recommend this cute ice cream place!

What a great experience from start to finish. Make no mistake, the small business owners here work hard to provide the best possible ice cream. On my visit they were all hard at work making ice cream between filling all of the orders. My kind of place that is built on the everyday grind of hard work. Did I mention that the ice cream delivers at a high level. With a super competitive Morris County NJ Ice Cream market, they would be in the top 5 for sure. I cannot Wait to go back. They should do well on the 2024 Golden Cone App.

This is one of the best I’ve cream places in the area! So many different cone portions. A large variety of ice cream options and the most adorable sitting area. I had the NY cheesecake ice cream, my friend got the strawberry with chocolate fudge and my husband got the coffee with chocolate fudge. I normally love denville dairy, but this place was 100% better in that they had more options of ice cream and you can definitely get a large group together for ice cream here. I honestly think this would be great for a party. If you want some amazing ice cream in Morris county or Parsipanny, this is the place to go! Loved it

Omg!!! I could not be more pleased with my cake! When ordering I said my Mom likes green and plants. Well, never did I think I’d get this beautiful creation!! Huge shout out to Lake Hiawatha Dairy! Beautifully decorated and delicious, creamy ice cream! Thank you so much! My Mom is 92 years old and loved her cake so much!

Ice- cream cakes available with delifferent delicious flavors.

We had such a fantastic experience at The Dairy in Lake Hiawatha! Karen, the owner, and her daughter are not only incredibly talented but also genuinely kind and caring. They went above and beyond to create a stunning custom ice cream cake for my daughter's 6th birthday. From the beautiful decorations to the delicious flavor, every detail was thoughtfully crafted. You can tell they put their heart into their work. The cake was a huge hit—my daughter was thrilled, and all the guests couldn’t stop talking about how good it tasted. It’s rare to find that perfect mix of quality, creativity, and outstanding customer service. If you're looking for a special treat or a custom cake that’s both beautiful and delicious, I can’t recommend The Dairy enough. We'll definitely be back!

Lake Hiawatha Dairy